loading...
Tue, Oct 1511:38 pm UTCYankee Stadium
55 F
Track OnCBS Sports
Cleveland
Guardians
CLE
Last 5 ML
W/L96-74
ATS85-85
O/U72-86-12
FINAL SCORE
3
-
6
New York
Yankees
NYY
Last 5 ML
W/L102-74
ATS89-87
O/U93-78-5
SPREAD
MONEYLINE
OVER/UNDER
Last 5 ML
96-74
Win /Loss
102-74
85-85
Spread
89-87
72-86-12
Over / Under
93-78-5
SPREAD
MONEYLINE
OVER/UNDER

Simulation Picks

SPREAD
CLE @ NYY
Subscribers Only

Maximize Your Odds of Winning with SportsLine Model and Our Top-Rated Picks

MONEYLINE
CLE @ NYY
Subscribers Only

Maximize Your Odds of Winning with SportsLine Model and Our Top-Rated Picks

OVER / UNDER
CLE @ NYY
Subscribers Only

Maximize Your Odds of Winning with SportsLine Model and Our Top-Rated Picks

22%
PUBLIC
78%
MONEY
8%
PUBLIC
92%
MONEY
Over78%
PUBLIC
Under22%
Over
MONEY
Under

Understanding Public and Money

Think of 'Public' as the percentage of people betting on each side and 'Money' as how much money is being bet. When there's a big difference between the 'Public' and 'Money' data, it usually means that the more serious bettors (referred to as 'Sharp Money') are favoring a particular side.

Expert Picks

First 5 Innings - Total RunsFirst 5 Innings - Total Runs Under 3.5 +102
LOSS
Unit0.5
Erik's Analysis:

This has been a series that’s wearing out the under. Take this at plus money. Cole. Bibee. Bullpens.

Pick Made: Oct 15, 10:26 pm UTC on BetRivers
First 5 Innings - WinningFirst 5 Innings N.Y. Yankees -169
WIN
Unit0.5
Erik's Analysis:

Take Cole early. I know the environment will be electric for him. Let’s see Bibee match him. We don’t lose if it’s tied

Pick Made: Oct 15, 10:25 pm UTC on Caesars
Over / UnderOver 7 -105
WIN
Unit1.0
+1708
63-43-2 in Last 108 MLB Picks
+1160
28-15-2 in Last 45 MLB O/U Picks
+398
5-1 in Last 6 CLE O/U Picks
Micah's Analysis:

The Yankees are only hitting .218 in the playoffs but that doesn't account for seven walks in Game 1 which is just as good as seven hits. They've gone 4-1-1 in the last six meetings. Gerrit Cole has gone over two of his last starts against Cleveland. We also have the build-up of waiting for Aaron Judge to hit a home run. I think he hits one today and this game gets over.

Pick Made: Oct 15, 5:50 pm UTC on Caesars
Money LineN.Y. Yankees -167
WIN
Unit1.0
+1708
63-43-2 in Last 108 MLB Picks
+634
20-14 in Last 34 MLB ML Picks
+320
4-1 in Last 5 NYY ML Picks
Micah's Analysis:

The Yankees are up over Cleveland 1-0 and game two has Gerrit Cole starting. The Yankees have won his last four starts with Cole only allowing five earned runs in those starts. The Yankees have won three in a row over Cleveland and seven of nine. Cole has also won three straight against Cleveland the last two staying under and his only start against them this year was 6-0 with him allowing only one hit. Yankees are only hitting .218 in the playoffs but they get by. Yankees win.

Pick Made: Oct 15, 5:04 pm UTC on BetRivers
Point SpreadN.Y. Yankees -1.5 +136
WIN
Unit1.0
+1732
229-217-4 in Last 450 MLB Picks
+343
12-9 in Last 21 MLB ATS Picks
+368
10-8 in Last 18 NYY ATS Picks
Bruce's Analysis:

Disappearances by the Guardians offense are nothing new and recurred throughout the season and even in the ALDS vs. the Tigers before recovering. Tanner Bibee hasn't even been lasting five innings in recent starts, so Stephen Vogt is going to have to look hard at his bullpen in Game 2 (and for however long Cleveland lasts in this series). Meanwhile, Aaron Boone is going to be confident in starter Gerrit Cole, who has been sharp since the start of August, and a 2.40 ERA across his last thirteen starts. Boone would gladly settle for a repeat of Cole's seven innings in last Thursday's decider vs. the Royals, allowing just one run in 7 IP of a 3-1 Yankees clincher. Play Yankees on Run Line

Pick Made: Oct 15, 5:26 am UTC on DraftKings
Money LineN.Y. Yankees -167
WIN
Unit1.0
+1027.25
78-44 in Last 122 MLB ML Picks
+2324
59-25 in Last 84 CLE ML Picks
Matt's Analysis:

Game 1 was largely stress-free for the Yankees. Anthony Rizzo's return from injury after missing the ALDS made a difference in the lineup. Giancarlo Stanton is hitting. Aaron Judge seemed to have a few good at-bats as he battles a slump (still no hits). Now it's Gerrit Cole on Tuesday, and he's obviously a playoff veteran -- off a terrific ALDS clinching Game 4 in Kansas City -- while 25-year-old counterpart Tanner Bibee's two career playoff outings for Cleveland were in the ALDS vs. Detroit. He didn't go five innings in either. This probably only goes up with all the NY/Cole money.

Pick Made: Oct 15, 3:15 am UTC on BetMGM

Best Prop Picks

Subscribers Only
Markets have not been released for this game yet. Please check back soon for prop projections.Join Now

Best prop picks are generated from a combination of Sportsline's projection, analysis of the opposing team, and the bets value based on the current odds.

Team Injuries

Cleveland Guardians
Saturday, May 24, 2025
Avatar
CF
Micah Pries
CalfIl
Friday, May 23, 2025
Avatar
SP
Ben Lively
ElbowIl
Thursday, May 22, 2025
Avatar
RF
Will Brennan
ForearmIl
Wednesday, May 14, 2025
Avatar
SP
Shane Bieber
ElbowIl
Monday, May 05, 2025
Avatar
RP
Paul Sewald
ShoulderIl
Monday, Apr 28, 2025
Avatar
SP
Jack Leftwich
UndisclosedIl
Avatar
RP
Trevor Stephan
ElbowIl
Saturday, Apr 26, 2025
Avatar
RP
Erik Sabrowski
ElbowIl
Tuesday, Apr 08, 2025
Avatar
SP
John Means
ElbowIl
Saturday, Mar 29, 2025
Avatar
C
David Fry
ElbowIl
Monday, Feb 17, 2025
Avatar
RP
Sam Hentges
ShoulderIl
New York Yankees
Thursday, May 22, 2025
Avatar
RP
Fernando Cruz
ShoulderIl
Wednesday, May 21, 2025
Avatar
RP
Luis Velasquez
UndisclosedIl
Avatar
OF
Cole Gabrielson
UndisclosedIl
Monday, May 19, 2025
Avatar
SP
Luis Gil
LatIl
Avatar
SP
J.T. Brubaker
RibsIl
Avatar
RP
Edgar Barclay
UndisclosedIl
Sunday, May 18, 2025
Avatar
RP
Kevin Stevens
UndisclosedIl
Saturday, May 17, 2025
Avatar
SP
Gerrit Cole
ElbowIl
Avatar
3B
Oswaldo Cabrera
AnkleIl
Avatar
RP
Jake Cousins
ForearmIl
Tuesday, May 13, 2025
Avatar
DH
Giancarlo Stanton
ElbowIl
Sunday, May 11, 2025
Avatar
SP
Marcus Stroman
KneeIl
Friday, May 02, 2025
Avatar
2B
Jazz Chisholm
ObliqueIl
Wednesday, Mar 26, 2025
Avatar
SP
Jayvien Sandridge
UndisclosedIl

Season Splits

All Games
ALL
All Games
58%
97-70, +1783
93-73, -302
56%
On Road
LOCATION
At Home
54%
46-38, +1187
46-38, -859
54%
As Underdog or Even
STATUS
As Favorite
49%
38-39, +846
72-43, +346
62%
When Line was +126 to +156
MONEY LINE
When Line was -183 to -153
54%
12-10, +681
21-12, +61
63%
As Road Underdog
LOCATION & STATUS
As Home Favorite
49%
28-29, +810
42-28, -281
60%
vs Teams That Win >54% of Games
OPP WIN%
vs Teams That Win >54% of Games
49%
25-26, +309
36-29, -27
55%
vs Teams Allowing 3.9 to 4.2 Runs
OPP DEFENSE
vs Teams Allowing <3.9 Runs
41%
18-25, -607
18-16, -249
52%
2nd game without a day off
REST
2nd game without a day off
46%
12-14, -332
13-8, +224
61%
vs NYY
HEAD TO HEAD
vs CLE
25%
1-3, -192
3-1, +129
75%
when Tanner Bibee starts
PROJECTED STARTER
when Gerrit Cole starts
79%
19-5, +1010
5-5, -220
50%
© 2025 CBS INTERACTIVE INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. SportsLine and SportLine PRO are registered trademarks of SportsLine.com, Inc.FANS ONLY
In partnership with...247 Sports

FOLLOW US:

The content on this site is for entertainment purposes only and SportsLine makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event. There is no gambling offered on this site. This site contains commercial content and SportsLine may be compensated for the links provided on this site.