MLB DFS, 2026: Top FanDuel, DraftKings picks, lineups, advice for Tuesday, May 12 from a daily Fantasy pro

There's a full 15-game slate on Tuesday's MLB schedule, providing a deep MLB DFS player pool at both the plate and on the mound. For the latter, top pitching options for daily Fantasy baseball lineups include Paul Skenes and Yoshinobu Yamamoto. Meanwhile, an underrated hitter to potentially insert into your MLB DFS strategy is Philadelphia's Brandon Marsh. He has both the longest active hitting streak (12) in the majors and tops all of baseball with a .353 average.

Before making any MLB DFS picks on sites like DraftKings and FanDuel for this slate, you need to see what Mike McClure has to say.

McClure is a DFS professional with over $2 million in career winnings. He's also a predictive data engineer at SportsLine who uses a powerful prediction model that simulates every minute of every game 10,000 times, taking factors like matchups, statistical trends and injuries into account.

This allows him to find the best MLB DFS values and create optimal lineups that he shares only at SportsLine. They're a must-see for any MLB DFS player.

For Tuesday, one of McClure's top MLB DFS picks is Dodgers DH Shohei Ohtani ($6,500 on DraftKings, $3,800 on FanDuel). He's also building around Rays third baseman Junior Caminero ($5,400 on DraftKings, $3,500 on FanDuel), who has a pair of homers, four runs scored and has reached base safely six times over his last four games.

McClure is also targeting a surprising player who could go off for massive numbers on Tuesday! This pick could be the difference between winning your tournaments and cash games or going home with nothing. You absolutely need to see who it is before locking in any lineups.

What are the top MLB DFS picks for Tuesday? ... Join SportsLine now to see DFS pro Mike McClure's top picks, stacks, and player pools for FanDuel and DraftKings, and cash in BIG on MLB DFS!