NFL odds, picks: Who's the better value for Defensive Rookie of the Year, Arvell Reese vs. David Bailey?
With eight weeks remaining in the regular season, one of the rookies from New York is the clear play in the market


For as long as they're in the NFL, David Bailey and Arvell Reese will be compared against each other.
In April's NFL Draft, the New York Jets had the No. 2 overall pick and reportedly were down to pass-rushing terror David Bailey from Texas Tech and do-it-all linebacker Arvell Reese from Ohio State. The Jets chose the former. "We just felt like Bailey fit us better," coach Aaron Glenn said at the time.
After both the Cardinals (running back Jeremiyah Love) and Titans (receiver Carnell Tate) went offense with picks No. 3 and 4, the Giants gobbled up Reese at No. 5, setting the stage for the juicy debate that is sure to get plenty of air time on sports talk shows in the Tri-State area for years to come: Did the Jets make the right call with Bailey at No. 2?
Half a season is much too small of a sample size to make any kind of determination, but here are the stats so far: Bailey has 7.5 sacks (most among rookies), 10 tackles for loss (also the most), five forced fumbles (most among rookies and tied for the most in the league) and 45 total tackles (11th) for a 2-8 Jets team that has been average defensively (332.1 yards per game). He ranks 55th among 111 qualified edge defenders, rookies and veterans alike, according to Pro Football Focus.
Reese, meanwhile, has 4.5 sacks (second only to Bailey among rookies), eight tackles for loss (also second to Bailey), 51 solo tackles (most) and one forced fumble, fumble recovery and interception for a Giants defense that ranks fifth in the league (305.7 total yards per game). Because of his versatility, Reese ranks eighth among 82 all qualified linebackers, according to Pro Football Focus.
Reese and Bailey are turning the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year award into a two-man race. Reece is the -155 favorite at DraftKings, with Bailey the +300 second choice. Commanders linebacker Sonny Styles is the third choice, at +950.
But with eight weeks remaining in the regular season, does either Reese or Bailey provide value at those odds. Or should value players look elsewhere?
Join now to unlock this story plus unlimited picks from our computer model and 40+ experts
Join NowAlready a subscriber?Sign In