Nagel's Big Three for CFB Week 1
Josh Nagel gives his top three point-spread picks for the opening weekend of college football, which include backing a touchdown underdog in a high-profile battle.


Although there are plenty of enticing Week 1 college games, good picks are difficult to come by.
After studying the spreads and data for the opening games, here are my top three selections for this week.
South Carolina vs. North Carolina
Click here for SportsLine's pick and projection for South Carolina-North Carolina
Kickoff: Thursday, 6 p.m. ET (Charlotte)
TV: ESPN
Spread: South Carolina -2.5, O/U 64
Analysis: Led by dynamic dual-threat quarterback Marquise Williams and a load of speedy playmakers, the Tar Heels should have one of the most explosive offensive units in the country.
Normally, a finesse offense would be a bad fit against a rugged SEC defense, but this matchup is a notable exception.
The Gamecocks are rebuilding on both sides of the ball. They have a quarterback in Connor Mitch who will be making his first start, and just six returning starters from what was a vulnerable defense last year.
South Carolina coach Steve Spurrier will make the most of his resources and keep it competitive, but it won't be enough against the potent Tar Heels.
Although North Carolina had one of the worst defensive units in the country last year, the Gamecocks don't have enough threats to exploit it.
The Tar Heels have too much firepower for South Carolina to keep pace.
Pick: North Carolina +2.5
Predicted final score: North Carolina 41, South Carolina 27
BYU at Nebraska
Click here for SportsLine's projection and pick for BYU-Nebraska
Kickoff: Saturday, 3:30 p.m. ET
TV: ABC
Spread: Nebraska -7, O/U 60.5
Analysis: Nebraska enters a new era, with former Oregon State coach Mike Riley making his debut as head coach for the Cornhuskers.
Riley reportedly is turning dual-threat quarterback Tommy Armstrong, who was second on the team in rushing last year, into a pro-style pocket passer.
This likely is a bad idea. We've seen what happens when coaches try to fit their philosophy to the personnel they inherit, instead of the other way around (Rich Rodriguez's short tenure at Michigan comes to mind).
BYU is led by a veteran dual-threat quarterback in Taysom Hill, who has been mentioned as a potential Heisman candidate.
Hill passed for 975 yards and seven touchdowns last season and ran for 460 more and eight scores before suffering a season-ending injury in Week 5 against Utah State.
Moreover, BYU coach Bronco Mendenhall, a defensive specialist, is taking over the defensive play calls after the Cougars allowed 55 points to Memphis in their Miami Beach Bowl defeat.
The Cougars have the edge in stability, experience and coaching. I expect them to be the better-prepared team here, and believe the touchdown underdog spot provides immense value.
Pick: BYU +7
(Note: The consensus line is now BYU +5 as of 3 p.m. ET Saturday)
Predicted final score: BYU 38, Nebraska 31
Texas at Notre Dame
Click here for SportsLine's projection and pick for Texas-Notre Dame
Kickoff: Saturday, 7:30 p.m. ET
TV: NBC
Spread: Notre Dame -9.5, O/U 51.5
Analysis: Defense should be strong for both clubs, as the Irish return 10 defensive starters and Texas coach Charlie Strong already has made an impact on that side of the ball for the Longhorns.
The Longhorns last season were solid in most defensive statistical categories. They led the Big 12 in passing defense (184.2 yards per game) and were No. 25 nationally in total defense (348.5 yards per game).
Their struggles came on offense, where they ranked No. 106 nationally in scoring at 21.4 points per game.
Offense should again be a question mark, as a running game led by standout back Johnathan Gray will be featured to take pressure off erratic quarterback Tyrone Swoopes.
The Irish defense should be vastly improved from a unit that gave up 29.2 points per game (No. 82 nationally) last season.
Meanwhile, Notre Dame will debut a talented but inexperienced quarterback in sophomore Malik Zaire, who is getting the nod in the wake of Everett Golson's transfer to Florida State.
While Zaire should prove a capable playmaker, expect the Irish also to try and establish a ground game behind speedy back Tarean Folston.
I anticipate this game will be dominated by time-consuming drives, few of which will result in a touchdown payoff.
The spread might be a close call, but these teams should fight a physical battle that will lead to a final score coming in comfortably Under the posted total.
Pick: Under 51.5
(Note: The consensus O/U total is 49 as of 3 p.m. ET Saturday).
Predicted final score: Notre Dame 24, Texas 16
Josh Nagel is a Reno-based handicapper and radio host who has worked in the Nevada sports gaming industry for 15 years. His work has been featured in USA Today, Poker News and on Covers.com. He looks for psychological edges, motivational spots and situational advantages.