Rays starter Charlie Morton is getting a lot of respect at this price, but if you dig a bit closer, you'll see that he has given up nine earned runs on 11 hits over his last two starts (9.0 innings total). Meanwhile, Cleveland's Adam Plutko is coming off a career outing in Detroit, striking out a career-high nine batters and allowing only one run and three hits in 5.2 innings against the Tigers. I'll take a shot with the Indians at this great price.