|
Trade Sabathia?
Coming into the season, I think I would have agreed with that since there is absolutely no way the Indians will be able to afford to keep him, so might as well get something for him in return. But now that we are 1/4 of the way through the season, I see it from a different point-of-view: The Indians best chance to win it all is this year. Think about it...Boston is still Boston but they are aging and can be beaten. They are not as dominant this year as they were last year. The Yankees will rebound but again, they are not dominant. They have issues with depth and age and injuries. Oakland and LAA are contenders but as we just saw, Oakland can't hit good pitching. There is no team running away with it this year, at least not in the AL, so the Indians have a legitimate shot at winning it all this year. While the majority of fans would rather have a more promising future rather than one year, the city of Cleveland and its fans needs a championship. No Cleveland team has won a championship in any sports in about 389 years. If they trade CC, their rotation in the playoffs would be Carmona, Cliff Lee, and then a combination of Westbrook, Byrd, and Laffey. You need 3 great starters and that would only give them two. Laffey is really good but has no postseason experience so he couldnt be counted on. Westbrook choked in Game 7 and is a contact pitcher. Byrd is ancient. They are doing well this year, no doubt, but that is not who I would want pitching Game 3, 4, and 7. With Sabathia, Carmona, and Lee, that gives you a dominant pitcher in 6 of 7 games, rather than 4 of 7. It's a tough call...they definitely need a bat, and a lead off hitter would allow Grady Sizemore to hit third in front of Victor Martinez.
|