powered by Google  
  Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 


Community | Help
Coaching Power Rankings Sports News
  Home   Fantasy     NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  Racing  |  Tennis  |  Olympics  |  MMA  |  More CBS College | High School | Mobile | Shop  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 Horses Home
 Live Racing
 Youbet Update
 Carryovers
 Free Selections
 Contests
 U. of BET
 Message Board
 
 
 
 
 Cycling Home
 Results
 Standings
 Stages
 Teams
 Riders
 Message Board
 
 
 
 
 
 
 Arena Football
 Boxing
 CBS College Sports
 CBS Sports TV
 College Baseball
 College Hockey
 Collegiate Nationals
 Horse Racing
 Message Board
 Poker
 Soccer
 SPiN
 Tour de France
 Video
 WNBA
 Women's Coll BK
 World Sports
 
 Site Index
 
 
 CBS College Sports
 Coll Sports Tonight
 Get CBS Coll Sports
 XXL - Watch Now
 Talent Bios
 Schedules
 School Sites
 
 
 Find your School
 '08 Football Preview
 Football Rankings
 Football Stats
 Hoops Recruiting
 Hoops Rankings
 Hoops Stats
 Video Highlights
 
 
 Featured Application
 Mobile Web
 Alerts
 Applications
 Video
 
 
 Home
 NFL
 NCAA
 MLB
 NBA
 NHL
 Fantasy
 
Community Home | My Profile | My Blog | Groups | My Settings | My Account | Member Search | Blog Search | About Community
 

Coaching Power Rankings


View Message BoardViews:      


Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Feb 11, 2007

May 13, 2008 2:45 pm

You're an Athletic Director of a large, public university playing in a BCS Conference with substantial financial resources and a passionate fan base.  You don't like the direction your program has been taking in recent years, so you decide to completely overhaul the football program, starting with the head coach.  In theory, you could have any coach you want to build your program... whom do you take and why?

Here's my list of the Coaching "Power Rankings"

1. Pete Carroll - Since returning to the college ranks, Carroll has built USC into the pre-eminent college football program in the country, producing an obscene amount of first round draft choices to go with his PAC-10 titles. 

2. Urban Meyer - Like a college football Midas, everything he touches seems to turn to gold.  First Bowling Green, then Utah, and finally Florida.  Expect the Gators to be in the title hunt.

3. Jim Tressel - His accomplishments at OSU have been nothing short of jaw-dropping, winning four Big Ten titles in seven years.  On top of all that, he's one of the classiest individuals in the sport.

4. Bob Stoops - It's not just the fact that he's established Oklahoma as one of the premier programs of the BCS era, guiding them to BCS bowls in an astounding 6 of his 9 years at helm, but how he's managed to keep his team relevant in seasons when his team has been beset by injuries and scandal.

5. Rich Rodriguez - Is there anyone who's breathed more life into a program in recent memory than did RR at West Virginia?  His terms of departure may have left the 'Eer faithful with a sour taste in their mouths, but they weren't within five city blocks of national relevance before he took charge.  It remains to be seen how he'll do at UM, but the Wolverines knew what they were doing in hiring this guy.

6. Mark Mangino - Quick, raise your hand if you expected Kansas to be relevant in FOOTBALL at a time when the likes of Texas, Oklahoma, and the rest were stockpiling talent in the Big XII. 

7. Les Miles - Still in the shadow of Nick Saban, but hopefully the National Title will go a long way towards establishing Miles as a top coach.

8. Dennis Erickson - Jeff Tedford's the only one who's challenged Pete Carroll's chokehold on the PAC-10 in recent years, and the Bears have struggled to get over the hump.  Enter Erickson, and the Sun Devils are suddenly giving the Trojans a run for the money out West, sooner than anyone had guessed.

9. Ron Zook - His turnaround at Illinois has shown that he's found a better fit than the Swamp.

10. Bobby Petrino - Abysmal NFL foray aside, he, along with Rodriguez, almost singlehandedly preserved the Big East's BCS bid following the departure of Miami, V-Tech, and BC.  That's saying something.

11. Brett Bielema - His first couple of seasons at Wisconsin have been outstanding--now it's time to see if he can take them to the top and win a Big Ten title.

12. Greg Schiano - When you can convince recruits to turn down Notre Dame to play for RUTGERS, you know you're one of the hottest coaches on the market.

13. Mark Richt - His stock could soar if the Bulldogs are able to win it all this year.  As of yet, he's done very well, but hasn't been able to break through.

14. Sylvester Croom - Hard to imagine a coach who's taken over a worse program in recent years and done a more impressive job with what he's been given.

15. Gary Pinkel - Since when are Missouri and Kansas the teams to beat in the Big XII?  Since Pinkel and Mangino arrived. 

16. Howard Schnellenberger - The only coach on this list who quite literally built a program from SCRATCH

17. Frank Beamer - No, the Hokies don't belong in the same breath with USC, Ohio State, and LSU... but the fact that he's kept them atop the Big East, and now the ACC, for as long as he has, says a great deal.  Sean Glennon ain't exactly Carson Palmer

18. Phil Fulmer - With a young team and a depleted receiver corps, Fulmer still managed to get the Vols to the SEC title game.  Now he's got to show he can challenge Florida, LSU, Auburn, and Georgia... and hold off Arkansas, Alabama, and South Carolina... year-in and year-out.

19. Mark Dantonio - If he could make Cincinnati a player, imagine what he'll be able to do at the reins of a Big Ten program like Michigan State, which he's already turned around. 

20. Brian Kelly - Like Dantonio before him, this is a guy who's name could well be mentioned for coaching vacancies at top programs over the next few years. 


Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Feb 11, 2007

May 13, 2008 2:47 pm

Okay, I did that off the top of my head, and without any stats.  So if you're going to come on and argue that Coach A at #17 has a winning percentage of .83 while the guy four spots above him is only at .79... I didn't do it that way.

Like I said, if I were building a program, that's the list of guys I'd call, more or less in that order.  If you see any conspicous omissions, or you can't BELIEVE I put Phil Fulmer on the list while leaving off Steve Spurrier, Charlie Weis, Mack Brown, and Jeff Teford, give me your thinking.

Otherwise, let's have your lists!! 


Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Apr 16, 2007

May 13, 2008 2:51 pm

Of course I take Richt.

He is a Christian man, he recruits great players on/off the field, his players are never in trouble. When he recruits, he only uses half of the resources.

This is Richts first head coaching job and he is already Top 5 in current coaching win %.

 


Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Feb 11, 2007

May 13, 2008 2:55 pm
I agree, Derek.  He's got potential to shoot up these rankings this season.

Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Apr 1, 2007

May 13, 2008 2:56 pm

What do you mean by heading in the wrong direction?

If by that you mean losing, then take Pete Carroll or Urban Meyer.  No offense to these guys, they are great coaches, but sneaky Pete knows his payers are getting benefits and Meyer, for every great person he recruits (Tebow) he gets a bad apple or two with them...

If you want a coach with integrity then Like Dross said, take Richt or Tressel, there are many to choose from.

I'm not bashing on Carroll or Meyer they were just the most notable examples...


Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Oct 20, 2006

May 13, 2008 2:56 pm
Here's a homeristic point, but you would seriously take Sly Croom over Tommy Tubberville?? Tubbs isn't even in your top 20. Please elaborate on that.

Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Apr 16, 2007

May 13, 2008 3:00 pm

Howlongitsbeen, I know its just your personal opinion, but Richt at #13?

When given the criteria and situation of starting fresh with a new coach, who would you take, how can you not say Richt is at least top 10, if not 5?

He started fresh at Georgia, his first HC job, since then he has consistantly given them Top 10 finish after finish in the standings and in recruiting.

He is the perfect fit for a big institution that wants to start over. He realizes the importance in depth and he makes sure everyone gets seasoned playing time.

Tubbs is in the same boat, like NLAuburn said. His players are never in trouble and he consistantly finishes better than expected.

Two classy guys with class act teams.


Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Feb 11, 2007

May 13, 2008 3:01 pm
As with any power rankings, they're subject to a whole lot of fluctuation, NLAuburn.  More like the stock market than an AP poll, if you will.  If I were ranking the Top 20 coaches since 2000, TT would indubitably be on that list.  Probably Top Ten.  But after three straight underwhelming seasons---not BAD, mind you, just underwhelming---he's slid a little in my book, and out of the Top 20.  Dominating Alabama in the Iron Bowl isn't enough when you've got the talent to be competing with the likes of Florida and LSU as the SEC's representative in BCS bowls.

Coaching Power Rankings
-
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Apr 16, 2007

May 13, 2008 3:02 pm
Also agree with osufanatic. I couldn't take Carroll, Meyers, Saban, etc. because they are boarderline good/bad with all thats going on. For everything good that happens, something bad is lurking in the shadows.