powered by Google  
  Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 


Community | Help
his solution is weak Sports News
Home    Fantasy    NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  Racing  |  Tennis  |  Cycling  |  MMA  |  More
CBS College  |  High School  |  Mobile  |  Shop
Community Home | My Profile | My Blog | Groups | My Settings | My Account | Member Search | Blog Search | About Community
 

his solution is weak


View Message Board ·  Return to StoryViews:      


his solution is weak
-
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 25, 2006

May 9, 2008 7:24 am

Great job pointing out the problem, but what's the solution? According to Doyle, here it is:

Call a foul every time a foul happens, and when the offending player and his coach object a little too much, call the technical, too. Let tonight's NBA playoff games be decided by free throws. And tomorrow night's. And the next night's, if that's what it takes. Make the 48th minute as unwatchable as possible. Eventually the players and coaches will get the message.

Uh...what?  The coaches and players, I'm sure, love having all that rest toward the end of the game to take a breather and save that last bit of energy for the final drive or final shot.  It's like getting a freebie timeout - multiple times - in the last minute of the game.  Coaches LOVE to win games at the free throw line.  They'd rather win by 20 points, sure, but in a close game, any NBA coach will tell you that they want to be at the free throw line so they can sink easy baskets - drive and get the foul.  If you don't get fouled - which is hardly ever at the end of a close game - you're going to make the layup a good percentage of the time.  And even if a defensive rebound occurs, you foul that guy and force HIM to win it at the line. 

This logic isn't going to just go away by having the refs blow the whistle more.  In fact it'll make it worse.  And besides, the NBA has already reduced trash talking and arguing with the refs to the point where you never see NBA players contesting fouls all that much anymore.  They might be given a little bit of leeway toward the end of the game as tempers flare, but not that much.  The problem of coaches and players complaining used to be a lot worse, and David Stern did, for once, do something that made sense when he eliminated that problem by threat of easily-acquired technical fouls.

I don't claim to have the solution but I know that Doyle's solution referenced above is not it.


his solution is weak
-
Reputation:47
Level:Rookie
Since:May 1, 2008

May 9, 2008 12:19 pm
The fact of the matter is the NBA is a league where there are repeated stoppages of play both for on the court fouls and for timeouts.  I couldn't agree more that the 48th minute needs to be called similiar to the first 47 minutes but that does nothing to stop the fact that theres an abundance of timeouts and that intentional fouling is part of the game and an effective strategy regardless of what effect it has on viewers at home.  The action is still there, so you need to wait a bit longer to see it evolve, if you're a fan you'll deal.  The biggest crime in the current system is again the fact that a guy driving with 30 seconds on the clock can't count on how the games been called to that point in regards to whether or not he might get a call.  That's a fairness issue, the viewers are there and will continue to be, make sure the game is legit.

his solution is weak
-
Reputation:81
Level:All-Star
Since:Feb 28, 2008

May 9, 2008 12:41 pm
His answer to this problem is pretty iffy, I dont think that'd work too well.

I would suggest using video reply in order to make the calls, just like in the NHL. i dont know how well it would work but it could be worth a try.

his solution is weak
-
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Nov 9, 2006

May 9, 2008 4:04 pm
First things first. Take away all timeouts, but one, for the final 3 minutes. These NBA games give out way too many time-outs, especially when you consider the amount of TV time-outs. This would reduce play stoppage, and would also show who has the intangibles down the stretch.