| |
Race in professional sports
|
|
|
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Apr 24, 2007
|
|
This article bothers me on many levels. Is the author trying to state that baseball has a diminishing number of african american players because of bias or racism? Are african americans being discriminated against due to an increase in latino ballplyers, or is it again an overt case of white america excluding black america? What if I wrote an article that lamented the fact that the NBA seems to becoming devoid of white players, and stated that it was the responsibility of the NBA, or our society, to increase the percentage of white players in the NBA. The article would be met with outcrys of racism and indignation, but that is exactly what is happenning now with this story, only in reverse with no public outcry. Why is that, is it because blacks have been discriminated against in the professional sports arena in the last twenty years? Is it because whites are paid more for producing less? I don't believe that is the reason, instead it would seem that for some reason young black men have deceided to apply their skills to other sports, predominantly basketball and football for whatever reason. Lets not look for conspiracies in places they don't exist, creating issues that are not relevant. If the conversation is relevant bring it, like the issues regarding fair housing and employment practices. But let's not inject race into issues that they don't have bearing on.
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:69
Level:Pro
Since:Aug 22, 2006
|
|
A- freaking men man. nice post
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Nov 21, 2006
|
|
Beautiful post. I couldn't have said it any better.
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:36
Level:Rookie
Since:Apr 10, 2007
|
|
I don't now if there was an implicit accusation of racism, but there certainly was no explicit claim of racism in baseball. The article, as I read it, simply noted that despite the fact that fewer african americans played MLB, a greater proportion were now represented in management.
Knowing the history of baseball, we must assume that these statistics are kept and are likely reported every year or two. I don't see any claims of bias in the article.
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Jan 22, 2007
|
|
I think its pretty clear why African-Americans (and others too) are gravitating to careers in pro football and basketball. In basketball you can become a millionaire at 19 and football two or three years later. In baseball, you probably can't get to the max-money level until you're at least in your late 20s. Unless you're someone like A-Rod, you have to put in your time in the minors and work your way up.
If you want to collect your chips real quick, baseball isn't your sport.
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:36
Level:Rookie
Since:Apr 10, 2007
|
|
err.. where did anyone claim racism in terms of players. The article simply states that there are fewer black players while the proportion in management has gone up.
In terms of management, there is a strong history of discrimination in baseball, ergo why they keep the stats.
That you picked 20 years in your post means you know some of the recent ugly history of MLB mgt. Let's not forget it was 20 years ago (1987) that Al Campanis, the head of Dodgers personnell, gave us his insights (have fun googling). i assume some of his ilk have learned that you can think and act on it, but not advertise these thoughts in an ABC interview.
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Sep 28, 2006
|
Is the author trying to state that baseball has a diminishing number of african american players because of bias or racism? No
Are african americans being discriminated against due to an increase in latino ballplyers, or is it again an overt case of white america excluding black america? No
The author isn't trying to imply anything, so stop trying to infer anything. It is simply a statement of statistics. Major League Baseball has had a concerted effort for some years to increase its popularity in inner-cities, this stat is kind of like a progress report.
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Apr 24, 2007
|
|
If bias or discrimination were not implied why would this be an issue? Wouldn't it be as news worthy to write an article, or many articles, about the lack of white players in the NBA? What if Hubie Brown, just an example, used his position on TNT, like Joe Morgan does on ESPN baseball telecasts, to lobby for the increase in white american participation in basketball to more closely resemble the percentage it reflected in the 70's?
It would be irresponible of me to ignore the years of bigotry and racism that existed in the past and may still exist today in some places. But because Al Campanis made racisist comments on nightline twent plus years ago does that still mean that racism and bigotry are pervasive in the upper levels of MLB management? I don't know, as I am sure few others do either. By this logic wouldn't that make all african american reverends racist and bigoted towards whites based on the past sermons of Rev. Jeremiah Wright? To say that, and demean the majority of african american clergy that love, respect and value the white americans that they share the country, city and country streets as well as possibly share their Sunday service with would be equally irresponsible.
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Sep 28, 2006
|
I think it would be just as newsworthy to write a story on white's not being in basketball, as long as you are sticking to the facts, like this story is. That trend is just as newsworthy.
Go ahead and write the story or call on this study group to release their findings on that issue.
|
Race in professional sports
|
Race in professional sports
|
Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Apr 24, 2007
|
|
Are you being serious? It is clear that the impication is that baseball is trying to overcome bigotry and racism in their hiring practices, both past and present. If this wasn't an issue why wouldn't the stuudy provide similiar statistics for white players as well? Wouldn't the comparison be relevant? Instead the only mention is of black players and their percenta | |